The BBC's Civil War Over Gaza
The BBC is facing an internal revolt over its reporting on Israel’s war on Gaza. Owen Jones investigates.

## Unbiased Reporting on Israel-Palestine Conflict: Internal Revolt at the BBC### BBC's Coverage Under ScrutinyThe renowned British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) has faced an internal rebellion over its coverage of Israel's unrelenting assault on Gaza.### Lack of ImpartialityJournalists and staff members within the BBC have voiced concerns about a deep-seated bias in the organization's reporting, alleging that efforts to address these concerns have been largely met with silence. They contend that the coverage has favored Israeli narratives and consistently devalued Palestinian lives.### Allegations of Systematic Israeli PropagandaA key figure cited in the internal complaints is Raffi Berg, BBC News online's Middle East editor. Journalists accuse Berg of heavily influencing news output on Israel-Palestine and suggest that he has the power to reframe stories, often minimizing or omitting unfavorable information about Israel.### Staff Outrage and Formal LettersIn November 2023, over 100 BBC employees signed a letter expressing dissatisfaction with the BBC's coverage of Gaza and other broadcasters. The letter outlined specific demands to improve impartiality, including highlighting Israeli non-cooperation in allowing journalists into Gaza and emphasizing the reliability of Palestinian sources.### BBC Management's ResponseBBC management initially dismissed claims of censorship, asserting that the BBC values its journalistic independence and engages with external stakeholders. However, dissenting staff claim that they often face resistance or indifference when raising concerns.### Inadequate Amnesty International CoverageInternal criticism intensified in December 2023 after the BBC's news website failed to adequately highlight Amnesty International's report alleging Israeli genocide against the Palestinian people. Senior correspondents expressed dismay at the perspective chosen for limited broadcast coverage, suggesting a reluctance to antagonize Israel.### Manipulation and Bias in News IndexJournalists suggest that the organization's Middle East news website index has been "micromanaged" by Berg. They allege that Berg strategically places articles and topics to favor Israeli viewpoints, further compromising impartiality.### Influence of Top BrassTim Davie, BBC's director general, and Deborah Turness, CEO of BBC News, have been implicated in stunting progress toward more unbiased coverage. Journalists report that despite evidence of Berg's influence and staff concerns, they have remained unresponsive.### BBC's Global ImpactThe BBC is a highly influential news organization globally, with a vast online presence. Its coverage significantly shapes perceptions of both Israeli and Palestinian narratives.### BBC Stands By Coverage and BergThe BBC has publicly maintained its unwavering support for Berg and the impartiality of its coverage. It has rejected accusations of favoritism and asserted its position as the "world's most trusted international news source."### Concluding ThoughtsDespite internal dissent and accusations of bias, the BBC continues to support its current approach to reporting on the Israel-Palestine conflict. Critics argue that the coverage fails to adequately represent the human toll and violates the BBC's commitment to fairness and impartiality. As the conflict persists, the need for balanced and unbiased reporting remains crucial to foster understanding and prevent further escalation.